Entitled new parents move into mother-in-law's house, get offended when told to pay their own expenses: 'If I was not helping her, she would be homeless'

Advertisement
  • An older woman wearing glasses rubs her temples while sitting down and looking stressed
  • Am I wrong for potentially ruining my brother and SIL financially?

    My brother and sister in law recently had a child together, which is awesome but I also found out they actually don't pay rent to our mom. They are staying in her old house, she wanted to downsize and move back home for better weather. Things have been tight
  • for her so I help her out. I thought they were paying the property taxes and general upkeep of the house. Turns out they do not even pay her rent, apparently they are also struggling.
  • Which I understand since they live in NY, cost of living can be nutty. What got me was when my mom told me my SIL made the choice to not go back to work. Which is confusing since she made more than my brother. She wants to stay home with their kid, fair but on mu brother's income they cannot afford to pay any rent or housing expenses.
  • Mom wants to make me responsible for her finances she essentially does not want to worry about bills and stuff going forward. Which I don't have a problem with, just the expenses on her old house are adding up. She finished the basement for them to give them more space. She also pays their carpayment, phone, internet, and ezpass.
  • If i was not helping her she would be homeless. I told her we need to change up this agreement because she cannot sustain it. She pretty much told me I can handle it however I see fit. Which is annoying but it is what it is.
  • A dad holds a newborn baby as a mom leans her chin on his shoulder
  • So I did have a talk with my brother and it did not go well. More or less told him things are going to change mom will not be subsidize their life style. I acknowledge they want a parent to stay with their kid, so I asked why doesn't he stay home and she goes back to work. To put into perspective she was a Nurse and he is a teacher, she made much more than him.
  • He said she wants to be home. I said i get it but they cannot afford to do that He said yes they could, I told him no they cannot only reason they are making it work is because mom is covering majority of their expenses and they are not paying rent.
  • He is upset because he feels mom should tell him this, I told him mom said I could handle it. I don't want to be the bad guy but mom cannot sustain this, she is barely getting by.
  • Time went on and nothing has changed, so last month I told him that starting in April mom was going cut back on stuff. I have to figure out what to do with the car since it is in our mom's name. Possibly will sell it then pay the rest off if we cannot sell it at a high enough price to wipe out the financed amount.
  • Told him we are canceling the internet, phone, and ezpass. As for rent I have been looking how to legally make tenants with a proper lease. Speaking with a landlord and tenant attorney.
  • My brother and SIL are miffed because they feel I am being petty and overzealous with how far I am going. Claiming I am willing to make my niece homeless. Not my intent, but they cannot keep abusing our mom like they have. She is going to be 68, she worked her a off over the years she has no
  • reason to struggling when she worked as hard as she did. Only reason she is struggling is because majority of her money goes to them.
  • They claim she wanted to do this and I somehow have convinced her otherwise. My mom is a chronic people pleaser and no she would never tell them no, cause they know exactly how to get her to cave. My SIL thinks I am because I suggested being also a she goes back to work. Implying I am telling them how to parent.
  • Here I am guess to vent and see maybe I am being overly harsh because I don't know what it is like to raise a family.
  • A man uses a calculator on top of a desk covered with papers
  • Teamtunafish NTA. You need to see a lawyer. Until that, asking on r/legal might not be a bad idea.
  • Ok-Intention-2832 Original Poster's Reply Not a bad idea. Thank you.
  • lordplagus02 Ask your brother and SIL why they thought it was a good idea to have a child and make it everyone else's problem.
  • Ok-Intention-2832 Original Poster's Reply They are 100% it takes a village type. They feel family is obligated to help those with children.
  • night_noche NTA but your mother is. She's a coward. She created them and now she's leaving it all up to you. Do you really believe her, that she's going to let this happen?
  • Ok-Intention-2832 Original Poster's Reply Our mom is a bl ding heart, yeah with the right talking points yeah. If they play the granddaughter card she would go bankrupt for her.
  • noonecaresat805 Nta. Besides the fact that you need a lawyer I have questions. Ok so it seems they have been living there for a while. They didn't pay rent or bills. What happened to all the money they were both making when they were both working? They seriously weren't able to save anything? What does his paycheck go to now? I mean your mom seems to be paying everything the only things they seem to pay is food and personal necessities. So what are they doing with the rest of the money? And you
  • StockAdhesiveness351 NTA. You could a bit more cutting if you want to. If it was my brother I would tell him "mom loves you too much to tell you that you are taking advantage of her. Your wife that could make more money isn't working because it's easier to just take advantage of our mother. You cant afford to take care of your own family so you leech off mom? You proud of yourself? When did you become so pathetic?" Shame that dude, he deserves to be shamed.
  • Regular_Giraffe_1879 NTA So here is the thing, they keep saying it's up to Mom but it isn't. Mom doesn't have the resources to provide for them. You are financing mom so in turn you are financing brother and sil. You get an opinion on the matter regardless of how they feel. You are not making your neice homeless. Your sister and brother both have careers that would afford THEM to provide for THEIR family. It is not up to YOU to provide for THEIR family. Time for them to be grown ups.
  • AnswerlsltDepends If they weren't paying anything for housing or the car WFT was the money even going to? I know teachers (some places) don't make much but seriously?!? NTA. Needs to have been cut waaaaaay back long ago.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article